Forthcoming cocoa securities now face crucial pricing test

by Business Post

Following the introduction of Ghana’s newly established Cocoa Capital PLC to an array of potential institutional investors such as pension funds, insurance companies and fund management firms, Ghana’s capital market has been primed for the upcoming GH¢16.3 billion issuance, potentially creating one of the largest new non-sovereign fixed-income offerings in the country in recent years. The securities are intended to support the forthcoming cocoa purchasing season and so COCOBOD had promised the detailed prospectus would be finalized ahead of the opening of the 2026/27 crop season.

The programme comprises up to GH¢14 billion of commercial paper with maturities of up to 270 days and about GH¢2.3 billion of bonds with maturities extending to five years, with the securities intended for listing on the Ghana Fixed Income Market.

Given that the investor engagement has already occurred and the programme details are now being circulated, the most plausible timetable is for the first issuance to take place in late September or October 2026, subject to completion of regulatory, listing and transaction documentation.

Subsequent commercial-paper drawdowns can then be staged through the crop season rather than attempting to raise the entire GH¢14 billion simultaneously.

banner

Armed with most of the information that potential investors will use to make an investment decision, focus has now turned to the most important consideration of all – the interest rates that each segment of the forthcoming issue will offer – and this is what is now under the microscope of capital operators and investors alike. Underpinning their ongoing permutations is the critical question of whether Cocoa Capital can price the securities sufficiently attractively to compete with Ghana Government securities without making cocoa financing prohibitively expensive for COCOBOD.

Expected commercial-paper pricing: about 11–12.5%

Investment bankers and financial market economists are not entirely in consensus on the coupon rates that will emerge shortly but they do agree that the strongest benchmark for the 270-day commercial paper is currently the Treasury-bill market.

As at the 21 September 2026 auction, the effective interest rate on the 364-day Treasury bill was 9.982 percent, while the 182-day bill yielded 6.489 percent and the 91-day bill, 4.694 percent.

But market analysts warn that Cocoa Capital cannot realistically be expected to price its 270-day paper at anything close to the 364-day Treasury-bill rate. A Treasury bill represents direct sovereign credit, whereas Cocoa Capital is a newly created special-purpose vehicle whose repayment depends primarily upon assigned cocoa export receivables.

The structure nevertheless provides important credit security. The programme envisages assigned export receivables from selected forward cocoa sales contracts, ring-fenced collection accounts, trustee oversight, a payment waterfall and a minimum 1.2-times receivables coverage ratio for debt-service obligations. Cocoa Capital PLC has instructively received an indicative A (Stable) rating, while its forthcoming commercial paper has been rated ST1 (Stable).

Those protections should keep the required risk premium substantially below that of ordinary unsecured corporate commercial paper.

The most widely held base-case expectation among market analysts is therefore for the 270-day paper to carry an annualized coupon/discount-equivalent return of approximately 11.0 percent–12.5 percent, with about 11.5 percent–12.0 percent the most plausible initial pricing band.

That represents a premium of roughly 150–250 basis points over the current 364-day Treasury-bill rate.

There is, however, a major complication, which is that investor demand is no longer uniformly abundant.

After many weeks of strong Treasury-bill subscriptions, the 18 September auction produced the first shortfall in 12 weeks. Investors submitted GH¢3.96 billion against a GH¢4.12 billion target, leaving a GH¢165 million, or approximately 4 percent, shortfall.

This is significant for Cocoa Capital. It means that although domestic liquidity is still substantial, investors are becoming increasingly selective about the return they require for committing funds.

Five-year bonds could require 13.5–15%

Pricing the longer-dated bonds is more complicated because investors must be compensated for the much longer investment duration which means much higher inflation and credit risk.

Analysts are pointing to the most useful recent benchmark being Ghana’s most recently issued four-year Government bond, which attracted GH¢4.46 billion of bids and GH¢3.15 billion of allocations at a 12 percent yield.

Secondary-market trading has subsequently lowered the new 2030 sovereign bond’s actual market yield to around 11.94 percent, while bonds maturing between 2031 and 2034 are trading at an average yield of approximately 13.90 percent.

Cocoa Capital therefore faces an obvious pricing dilemma.

A five-year Cocoa Capital bond yielding only 12 percent would offer investors virtually the same return as a recently issued four-year sovereign government bond while carrying additional credit and duration risk. That is unlikely to be sufficient.

The most probable range is therefore 13.5 percent–15.0 percent, with a central expectation of approximately 14 percent–14.5 percent for a five-year instrument.

However, most analysts note that the  actual coupon interest rate could be structured somewhat differently according to tenor—for example, lower coupons on two- or three-year bonds and a higher coupon for five-year maturities—but they insist that a roughly 200–250 basis-point premium over the new four-year sovereign benchmark appears necessary to compensate for the additional risk.

But there is another factor to consider – the benchmark Monetary Policy Rate which the Bank of Ghana’s Monetary Policy Committee will announce on Thursday September 24. Even a marginal change in the rate could affect commercial interest rates over the subsequent week or so.

Will investors subscribe?

There are grounds for believing that the programme can attract substantial funding, but probably only if it is priced close to these risk-adjusted levels.

The investment proposition is considerably stronger than that of a conventional corporate bond because repayment is linked to Ghana’s cocoa export cash flows rather than simply to Cocoa Capital’s standalone balance sheet.

COCOBOD’s reported financial recovery also provides an important backdrop. Its operating revenue during the 2025 financial year rose to GH¢48.6 billion from GH¢15.8 billion in the previous one, while cocoa production increased by 33.1 percent to 603,840 tonnes and the achieved FOB price reached US$5,174 per tonne. Provisional 2026 financial year production has reportedly reached about 771,000 tonnes.

The transaction’s structural protections consequently make the proposed return potentially attractive relative to the underlying risk.

But it is also being pointed out that investors will also compare it with the risk-free alternative.

A bank, pension fund or fund manager can currently obtain almost 10 percent from a 364-day Treasury bill without taking corporate credit risk. A five-year sovereign bond is available around 12 percent. Meanwhile, Ghana’s secondary bond market has recently offered yields around 13.5 percent–14 percent on some medium-term government securities.

Consequently, Cocoa Capital will have to offer enough additional yield to compensate investors for sacrificing sovereign-credit status.

The programme’s biggest advantage is that Ghana currently has a sizeable domestic savings pool.

Its biggest challenge is that this liquidity is being competed for by the sovereign, banks, money-market funds and other fixed-income investments.

The recent Treasury-bill data illustrates the changing balance. Strong demand earlier in September drove the 364-day yield down to 10.11 percent, but the latest auction produced a lower 9.98 percent yield alongside an overall subscription shortfall.

This suggests that investors have money available, but are increasingly unwilling to accept ever-lower yields.

For Cocoa Capital, that should translate into a relatively straightforward pricing proposition: pay enough of a premium to make investors indifferent between cocoa-backed securities and safer sovereign paper.

By: Toma Imirhe  / businesspostonline

You may also like